Expert Evidence

Expert evidence has long been used by English courts. It is often needed but experts have a variety of backgrounds. They can be competent and honest. They can be totally wrong. The police are prone to use experts who are going to tell them what they want to hear and that means guilty. When a man gets to the top of the medical profession he can be plausible, confident and arrogant. He can also be totally wrong. Should you assume that an expert is right? Not when you are in the frame. Here are some examples to make the point. Are judges going to see through the waffle?  Only if you are lucky. Juries can be fooled too.

Doctor Camille De San Lorenzo
Is a paediatrician who diagnosed dozens of children as victims of sexual abuse. Two nursery nurses alleged to be guilty as a result. The High Court gave her a life time ban on giving evidence in child abuse cases. While the General Medical Council took a more nonchalant position, saying merely that some of her work was "inappropriate, irresponsible and unprofessional". A libel Judge found that the woman  was "unbalanced, obsessive and lacking in judgment".

Would you believe that she is still a senior lecturer and an honorary consultant at the University of Newcastle, with clinical duties at the Royal Victoria Infirmary? Think twice before you take a child there. See page 28 of Private Eye 1198 for more and better details.

Roy Meadow
Professor Sir Samuel Roy Meadow (born 1933) is a British paediatrician who rose to initial fame for his 1977 academic paper on the now controversial Munchausen Syndrome by Proxy (MSbP) and his crusade against parents who willfully harm or kill their children. He was knighted for these works. He endorsed the dictum that “one sudden infant death is a tragedy, two is suspicious and three is murder, until proved otherwise“ in his book ABC of Child Abuse and this became known as Meadow's Law and at one time was widely adopted by social workers and child protection agency in Britain. 

He appeared as an expert witness, in which his testimony played a crucial part in wrongful conviction for murder. The General Medical (GMC) struck off Meadow after he was found to have offered “erroneous” and “misleading” evidence in the Sally Clark case. Clark was a lawyer wrongly convicted in 1999 of the murder of her two baby sons, largely on the basis of Meadow's evidence; her conviction was quashed in 2003 after she had spent three years in jail. Sally Clark died in 2007 from alcohol poisoning, apparently never having recovered from her wrongful imprisonment.

I dare say that Meadow would still claim that he was right. He fouled UP by his ignorance of elementary statistics and by assuming that sudden cot deaths are independent variables. The more fundamental error was his arrogance based on making to the top of the profession.

 

Marietta Higgs and the Cleveland child abuse scandal
Marietta Higgs was a paediatrician who had 121 children stolen from their parents using the powere of the courts and her very own test which had not been authenticated.  Higgs claims that she is not guilty and that there is far more abuse going on. She got away with it and still operational in Gillingham in Kent.

 

Is this doctor responsible for parents being falsely branded as child abusers?  [ 29 October 2007 ]
QUOTE
Dr Southall, has been praised as a pioneer by colleagues, while vilified as arrogant and dangerous by patients [ He looks an arrogant rogue and scruffy to boot- Editor ]. He has also been in trouble over remarks he made concerning the case of Sally Clark, the mother who was given two life sentences for the murder of her two children before being released after medical evidence emerged to prove she was innocent.....

The suspicion is that justice may have been perverted by the paediatrician because vital evidence in the files — which established that the children he diagnosed as victims of parental abuse had never been harmed but were, in fact, genuinely sick — was deliberately hidden from criminal court judges [ The legal term is perverting the course of justice - Editor ].
UNQUOTE
Marietta Higgs tried it on and had 121 children stolen from their parents. See The women who went through an ordeal beyond belief.  She may well be unrepentant to this day. Other medics backed her on a basis of deep ignorance. See Stuart Bell - the relevant MP and very good. Professor Sir Roy Meadow was  very dangerous  too.

 

Errors & omissions, broken links, cock ups, over-emphasis, malice [ real or imaginary ] or whatever; if you find any I am open to comment.
 
Email me at Mike Emery. All financial contributions are cheerfully accepted. If you want to keep it private, use my PGP KeyHome Page

Updated on 27/10/2008 11:04